Scaffolding contractors could have to prove that individuals are genuinely self-employed in tribunal disputes under government proposals to strengthen workers’ rights.
A government options assessment published on 29 October examines plans for a presumption of worker status at employment tribunals and changes to the weight given to personal service.
The preferred option carries an estimated equivalent annual net direct cost to business of £167.8m.
That is an economy-wide estimate for the proposals, not a charge on scaffolding firms or a forecast of this sector’s costs.
The assessment also identifies benefits that have not been given a monetary value, including worker wellbeing and a more level playing field for businesses already providing employment protections.
The proposals have not become law. The Make Work Pay consultation, launched on 14 October, seeks views on tackling bogus self-employment and strengthening protections for genuinely self-employed people.
The consultation covers England, Wales and Scotland and closes at 11.55pm on 8 January 2027. Employment law is devolved to Northern Ireland.
Worker status and substitution
One proposal would give less weight to personal service when deciding whether someone is a worker.
A contractual right to send a substitute would count for less where other features of the relationship point towards worker status.
A proposed presumption of worker status would put the burden of proving genuine self-employment on the business engaging the individual.
The consultation also seeks views on enforcement and a possible role for the Fair Work Agency.
For scaffolding firms using self-employed labour, the issue reaches beyond contract wording to how work is organised and who controls it.
Blacklisting and safety protections
Construction is singled out in the consultation document as an industry where blacklisting has historically been a particular problem.
The government asks whether protections should cover more self-employed people.
Other proposals explore protection against detrimental treatment for self-employed people taking appropriate action over serious and imminent workplace danger.
The consultation also considers a wider role for self-employed trade union members as safety representatives.
A proposed right to written statements would give genuinely self-employed people clearer information about their individual contracts.
The plans concern employment rights, not tax. The government announcement contains no proposals to change tax status or tax frameworks.
Businesses, workers, unions and representative bodies can respond before the January deadline. The government will consider submissions before publishing its response.


