Ad
Friday, October 31, 2025

Scaffolders tried to claim thousands in compo for whiplash

ADVERTISEMENT

Scaffolders tried to claim thousands in compensation after a council van collided with their lorry – at less than 2mph.

Town hall chiefs faced the threat of a £70,000 bill following the bump in slow-moving traffic.

The driver and two passengers in a lorry owned by S&S Scaffolding Ltd claimed they suffered whiplash in the collision with the van, and launched personal injury claims totalling £3,700.

The company, based in Atherton, near Wigan, also submitted a £6,430 claim for damages to the vehicle and for its ‘loss of use’.

Wigan council accepted blame for the collision but refuted both compensation claims and challenged the legal costs.

Now a judge at Bolton County Court has dismissed the action after hearing from two expert witnesses.

One, an independent engineer, said that the damage sustained by the lorry would have cost no more than £300 to repair.

And an eyewitness said both vehicles were travelling at between one and two miles per hour.

District Judge Shaw ruled that no injuries or any significant damage was caused and described the claim for the van’s damage and its loss of use as ‘wholly wrong’.

He also dismissed a legal bill of more than £50,000 and ordered that the council did not have to pay the £300 repair bill to the van. The council was awarded £9,332.

Council bosses today welcomed the ruling and said local authorities across the country were facing an increasing number of ‘grossly exaggerated’ claims involving low-speed road traffic collisions.

It was also revealed that the firm, based at Chanter’s Industrial Estate on Arley Way, Atherton, had carried out work on behalf of the council in the past.

The collision took place in Tyldesley, near Wigan, in 2008.

The lorry’s driver James Stubbs, of Henley Grove, Bolton, and passengers Thomas Gemmell and his son Gareth, of Hinkler Avenue, Bolton, brought the claim alongside the company.

Paul McKevitt from Wigan council said: “Local authorities across the country are facing an increasing number of claims from people who say they were injured in low speed impacts but this council is determined to scrutinise all allegations in order to protect public funds.

“It’s particularly disappointing, as this company has done work for the council in the past, and grossly exaggerated claims such as this are damaging to trust and future working relationships.

“The facts just didn’t stack up and by putting a coherent and persuasive defence before the court we have saved the council tax payers of this borough more than £70,000 of public money.”

“We hope this verdict sends a clear message that we will do all we can to protect public money and any claims that appear exaggerated will simply not succeed.”

The company refused to comment.

Mr Stubbs and Gareth Gemmell couldn’t be reached for comment. Thomas Gemmell declined to comment.

ADVERTISEMENT

Popular Categories

Latest news

House-building recovery delayed until 2029, industry warns

The Construction Products Association warns UK house-building will not recover to pre-pandemic levels until 2029 or 2030, urging government support for first-time buyers to prevent further insolvencies and job losses.

Staht secures largest ever distribution deal with Leach’s

One of the UK’s leading testing technology firms, Staht, has announced its largest ever distribution agreement after joining forces with Leach’s. The partnership will expand...

Avontus to host free webinars on digital scaffold management this November

Avontus Software has announced a series of free, live webinars in November designed to help contractors overcome the everyday challenges of tracking and managing...

Scaff25 announces global line-up of industry leaders for Sydney conference

The Scaffolding Association Australia (SAA) has revealed an impressive line-up of international speakers for its upcoming Scaff25 Annual Conference & Awards Night, set to...

Demolition firm issues statement following Manchester building and scaffolding collapse

Manchester-based demolition contractor P.P. O’Connor has released an official statement following Friday’s partial collapse of a building surrounded by scaffolding in the city centre. The...

Building and scaffolding partially collapses in Manchester city centre

A building in Manchester city centre has partially collapsed during demolition work, with scaffolding and debris seen falling into the nearby River Irwell. Emergency services...

Benchmark Scaffolding wins Silver at national awards

Benchmark Scaffolding has been recognised with the Silver Award in the Specialist Contractor of the Year category at the 2025 National Building and Construction...

Construction leaders unite against government plan to shorten apprenticeships

More than 20 construction organisations, including the NASC, have signed an open letter to Prime Minister Keir Starmer warning that plans to cut apprenticeships to eight months risk undermining skills, safety, and confidence in training.

HSE launches major construction site safety inspections in Manchester

The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) is carrying out a series of unannounced inspections at construction sites across Manchester city centre this week. Twelve inspectors...

JR Scaffold honoured with Ministry of Defence Silver Award

Paisley-based JR Scaffold has been recognised among a select group of leading Scottish businesses to receive the prestigious Silver Award from the Ministry of...

Latest news

ADVERTISEMENT

The magazine

Issue 27 | Past issues >>

Popular

Building and scaffolding partially collapses in Manchester city centre

A building in Manchester city centre has partially collapsed...

Demolition firm issues statement following Manchester building and scaffolding collapse

Manchester-based demolition contractor P.P. O’Connor has released an official...

ScaffChamp 2025: Teams Gather in Vilnius for Opening Day

The international scaffolding competition ScaffChamp 2025 has officially begun,...

Scaff25 announces global line-up of industry leaders for Sydney conference

The Scaffolding Association Australia (SAA) has revealed an impressive...

Staht secures largest ever distribution deal with Leach’s

One of the UK’s leading testing technology firms, Staht,...

Related articles

Scaffolders voted UK’s toughest trade

Scaffolders have been crowned the UK’s toughest trade by their fellow workers, according to new research – although the public believes roofers deserve the title. The nationwide study, commissioned by TROJAN workwear, polled tradespeople...
ADVERTISEMENTS

Latest topics

CISRS announces suite of new safety and inspection courses

The Construction Industry Scaffolders Record Scheme (CISRS) has announced...

House-building recovery delayed until 2029, industry warns

The Construction Products Association warns UK house-building will not recover to pre-pandemic levels until 2029 or 2030, urging government support for first-time buyers to prevent further insolvencies and job losses.

Staht secures largest ever distribution deal with Leach’s

One of the UK’s leading testing technology firms, Staht,...

Avontus to host free webinars on digital scaffold management this November

Avontus Software has announced a series of free, live...
ADVERTISEMENTS